Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression | HumanRights.gov is the official United States Government website for international human rights related information Skip Global Navigation to Main Content
Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression
Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression
Human Rights Council 35th Session - Geneva, Switzerland

Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression David Kaye

As delivered by Michele Roulbet

Thank you, Mr. Vice President.

The United States appreciates Special Rapporteur Kaye’s continued work on freedom of opinion and expression. We note the Special Rapporteur’s visit to Turkey. We are concerned by the crackdown on dissent, free expression, and independent media during the ongoing state of emergency, including through blocked websites and censorship of internet-based media. We continue to urge authorities to respect the freedom of expression of all people in Turkey and note the detentions of individuals such as Taner Kilic, Chair of Amnesty International Turkey, chill public debate and undermine the quality of democracy.

Mr. Kaye, we are also studying your recent report on Internet freedom and share your concern regarding state-sponsored disruptions designed to intentionally prevent or disrupt access to, or dissemination of, information.

We have concerns about several issues in the report, including the characterization of U.S. law and practice in certain instances. We would welcome the opportunity to review these concerns with you in more detail.

We would like to note:

  • The United States has consistently taken appropriate steps – and encouraged other States to do so – to prevent and counter the use of the Internet for criminal and terrorist purposes, while respecting fundamental freedoms, the free flow of information, and a free and open Internet. The United States has robust traditions and protections for these freedoms, including in its Constitution and judicial requirements.
  • We are concerned about the report’s widespread use of a “necessary and proportionate standard,” which is not grounded in the international law framework in the ICCPR.
  • The report’s discussion of net neutrality and zero rating does not acknowledge that the principles of a free and open Internet can be upheld through diverse approaches toward domestic law and regulations.
  • There have also been significant U.S. government efforts to declassify information concerning intelligence collection and otherwise increase transparency concerning national security issues since 2013, which are not mentioned in the report.
  • Finally, the United States does not view the Internet or access to the Internet as a public good. The same rights people have offline must be protected online, but this does not mean there is a human right to the Internet.

Question: Do you envisage doing further work on this topic? If so, what will be your focus?

Thank you.

Top Stories

USUN Remarks at a UN Security Council Briefing on the Situation in Afghanistan
Jun 21, 2017 | U.S. Deputy Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Michele Sison

In the context of these and other challenges Afghanistan continues to face, we strongly support the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan, UNAMA, as an essential partner of Afghanistan and the international community. UNAMA plays a critical role in supporting peace and reconciliation, empowering women, defending the human rights of all Afghans, and coordinating humanitarian assistance. We look forward to the completion next month of the Secretary-General’s strategic review and to discussing ways to strengthen the mission’s efficiency, cost effectiveness, and core competencies. ...Read More
Press Release
World Refugee Day
Jun 20, 2017 | Secretary of State John KerRex W. Tillerson

On World Refugee Day, we recognize the plight of those forced by persecution and war to flee their home countries. We also recognize the pressing challenges posed by ongoing refugee crises. Today, refugees number more than 22 million around the world.

The overwhelming majority of refugees want to go home to help rebuild their societies once the violence has stopped. As the single largest donor of humanitarian assistance the United States is ...Read More

Press Release
Ambassador Haley on World Refugee Day
Jun 20, 2017 | U.S. Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Ambassador Nikki R. Haley

The United States gives more humanitarian aid than any other country, but money alone is not enough—we must also work to end the conflicts that drive these people from their homes, while tearing apart their countries. We have lots of work to do at the UN, but the world's refugees and the countries that host them should know they can continue to count on the United States to lead,” said Ambassador Haley. ...Read More
Press Conference
Briefing on U.S. Participation in the General Assembly of the OAS
Jun 19, 2017 | U.S. Interim Representative to the Organization of American States, Kevin Sullivan; Deputy Assistant Secretary for Andean, Brazilian, and Southern Cone Affairs, Michael J. Fitzpatrick

We think the OAS’s work is vital to the advancement and protection of democracy and human rights, and building strong and effective democratic institutions, which are, of course, essential to lasting peace, prosperity, and stability in the region. The OAS also plays a critical role on anti-crime, anti-corruption, counter-narcotics and counterterrorism efforts, as well as to the region’s development and economic prosperity. ...Read More
Press Release
Item 6: General Debate on the Universal Periodic Review
Jun 19, 2017 | U.S. Delegation to the UN Human Rights Council

While many States have benefited from these exchanges and subsequently implemented reforms inspired or reinforced by their participation in the UPR process, the United States remains concerned about ongoing efforts by some States to stifle the participation of non-governmental organizations (NGOs). ...Read More